THE FATAL FLAW: COMMUNISM

A Promise That Became a Nightmare

Imagine being promised a paradise where no one goes hungry, everyone is equal, and the government eventually disappears. That's what communism offered. Millions believed it. Everywhere it was tried—from Russia to China, from Cambodia to Cuba—the result was the same: poverty, oppression, and death on a massive scale.

This isn't ancient history. Right now, North Koreans starve in prison camps for political crimes. Chinese citizens live under constant surveillance. Venezuelans flee their country by the millions despite living atop the world's largest oil reserves.

Why does communism always fail? The answer matters as new generations rediscover these ideas without learning history's bloodiest lessons. Over the coming weeks, we'll explore alternative systems—socialism, democracy, and the capitalist republic—to understand what actually works.

What Communism Actually Is

Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels laid out the communist vision in the mid-1800s. Marx gave collective ownership what seemed like a scientific framework.

Here's the basic pitch:

All of history is class warfare. One class has always exploited another—masters and slaves, lords and serfs, capitalists and workers.

Capitalism exploits workers. Business owners profit from the surplus value that workers create. You produce $100 worth of goods while getting paid $20 in wages.

Revolution is inevitable. Workers will eventually rise up, seize control, and create a temporary "dictatorship of the proletariat."

The state will wither away. Once private property is abolished and everyone is equal, government becomes unnecessary. People will work according to their abilities and receive according to their needs.

It appealed to people who saw real suffering during early industrialization—child labor, dangerous factories, grinding poverty. Marx promised a rational solution backed by the supposed laws of history.

There was just one problem: it was completely wrong.

Why It Can Never Work

The Calculation Problem: Flying Blind

Think about your local grocery store. How does it know how many apples to stock? Prices answer these questions automatically. When strawberries are scarce, prices rise, signaling farmers to grow more and consumers to buy less.

Now imagine abolishing all of that. No private property. No market prices. Just government planners trying to decide what the entire economy should produce.

How many shoes should the country make this year? What sizes? What styles? Without prices, planners are flying blind. Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises proved this wasn't just hard—it was mathematically impossible. Soviet factories produced millions of shoes no one wanted while people stood in line for hours to buy basics.

The Knowledge Problem: No One Knows Everything

The information needed to run an economy isn't sitting somewhere waiting to be collected. It's scattered in the heads of millions of people—a farmer who knows his specific soil, a shopkeeper who notices changing preferences, a worker who knows a faster method.

Friedrich Hayek called this "the knowledge problem." This practical, local knowledge can't be centralized. Markets allow people to act on what they know locally while prices coordinate the whole system.

Central planning tries to put all decisions in bureaucrats' hands. They can't possibly have this knowledge. The result? Chronic shortages, waste, and absurd inefficiencies.

The Incentive Problem: Why Work Hard?

When you can't keep the rewards of your hard work or innovation, why bother? There's a famous Soviet-era joke: "We pretend to work, and they pretend to pay us."

Soviet factory managers would hide their production capacity. If they exceeded their quota, next year's quota would just increase. Better to appear barely competent than to reveal you could do more.

The Power Problem: Total Control

Communism gives the government control over everything—not just political power, everything economic too. The state becomes your employer, landlord, grocer, doctor, educator, and information source.

If you upset the government, you lose your job, your home, your food ration, and possibly your freedom or life. That space for independence disappears entirely.

The Soviet Horror Show

The USSR lasted from 1917 to 1991. The results were catastrophic.

Lenin's Red Terror

Vladimir Lenin's Bolsheviks promised peace, bread, and land. They delivered civil war, starvation, and mass murder.

When peasants resisted having their grain confiscated, Lenin was explicit. In a 1918 telegram, he ordered: "hang (hang without fail, so the people see) no fewer than one hundred known kulaks, rich men, bloodsuckers."

Terror was policy, not an accident. The War Communism period killed approximately five million people through violence and famine.

Stalin's Engineered Famine

Joseph Stalin forced peasants into collective farms. The more successful farmers—"kulaks"—were killed, imprisoned in Gulag labor camps, or deported to Siberia.

The result was the Holodomor, the Ukrainian famine of 1932-33 that killed between 3.5 and 5 million people. The Soviet Union was exporting grain while Ukrainians starved. People ate bark, grass, and in desperate cases, resorted to cannibalism.

Children with swollen bellies died in the streets. Entire villages were depopulated. Stalin insisted everything was fine.

The Great Purge

From 1936 to 1938, Stalin's paranoia peaked. Show trials featured false confessions extracted through torture. Mass executions eliminated hundreds of thousands, possibly more than a million people.

Old Communist Party members were executed. Military officers were shot. Scientists who disagreed with Stalin's favored theories were imprisoned or killed. Ordinary citizens were denounced by neighbors or family members. No one was safe.

Economic Absurdity

Despite enormous natural resources, the Soviet economy was dysfunctional. Factory managers met their nail production quota by making one giant, useless nail. Stores had empty shelves while warehouses overflowed with goods no one wanted.

The Chernobyl nuclear disaster in 1986 revealed the systemic incompetence and corner-cutting that characterized Soviet industry.

The human toll is staggering: estimates range from 20 to 60 million people killed by the Soviet regime.

China's Communist Catastrophe

When Mao Zedong established the People's Republic of China in 1949, many hoped it would avoid Soviet mistakes. It repeated them at an even larger scale.

The Great Leap Forward: History's Deadliest Famine

From 1958 to 1962, Mao launched an ambitious plan to rapidly industrialize China. It produced the deadliest famine in human history.

Mao ordered the collectivization of agriculture and insisted peasants could make steel in backyard furnaces (they couldn't). He ordered sparrows killed as pests, which led to locust swarms that devastated crops.

Local officials, terrified of admitting failure, reported imaginary bumper harvests. Based on these lies, the state requisitioned grain that didn't exist. Between 30 and 45 million people starved to death.

Parents ate their dead children. Villages became graveyards. Mao maintained that China had never been better fed.

The Cultural Revolution

From 1966 to 1976, Mao unleashed the Cultural Revolution to destroy the "Four Olds": old customs, culture, habits, and ideas.

Students formed Red Guard militias and attacked teachers, intellectuals, and anyone deemed insufficiently revolutionary. People were beaten to death for owning books. Priceless historical artifacts were destroyed.

The death toll was between 1.5 and 2 million, with millions more persecuted.

Modern China

Today's China has abandoned communist economics. Market reforms that began in the late 1970s—allowing private businesses, foreign investment, and market prices—created China's economic growth. Prosperity came from moving away from communism.

Politically, the Communist Party maintains total control using modern technology. The social credit system monitors citizens' behavior. Over a million Uyghurs are detained in "re-education camps" where they face forced labor and cultural erasure.

Surveillance cameras with facial recognition track everyone. The internet is censored. Dissidents vanish.

The Pattern Repeats Everywhere

Cambodia: The Killing Fields

Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge (1975-1979) killed approximately a quarter of Cambodia's population—1.5 to 2 million people—in less than four years.

Cities were emptied. Anyone educated was executed. The entire nation became a forced labor camp. Children were taught to denounce their parents.

North Korea: The Hermit Prison State

The Kim dynasty has ruled since 1948, creating perhaps the world's most totalitarian state. Families are punished across three generations for political crimes. A famine in the 1990s killed perhaps 3 million people.

Defectors report that starvation is ongoing. Citizens eat grass and bark to survive. The ruling elite live in luxury while the population suffers.

Cuba: The Island Prison

Fidel Castro's revolution promised liberation. Sixty-plus years later, the average Cuban monthly salary is around $30. Thousands have risked their lives fleeing across the ocean to reach Florida.

Venezuela: Rich Country, Poor People

Venezuela had the largest proven oil reserves in the world. Under socialist policies, it collapsed. Hyperinflation made the currency worthless. Over 7 million people—about a quarter of the population—have fled.

Hospitals lack basic supplies. Grocery shelves are empty. Despite all that oil, there are chronic fuel shortages.

Addressing Common Objections

"That Wasn't Real Communism"

Every communist failure gets dismissed as a flawed implementation of the pure idea.

At some point, a theory that fails every time it's tried is just a bad theory. Soviet Union? Failed. China under Mao? Failed. Cambodia? Failed. North Korea? Failed. Cuba? Failed. Venezuela? Failed.

The common factor isn't bad luck or incompetent leaders. It's the system itself.

"What About Nordic Countries?"

Sweden, Denmark, and Norway aren't socialist—they're capitalist countries with large welfare states. They have private property, free markets, and competitive businesses. Their prosperity comes from capitalism. They just redistribute some wealth through high taxes.

The Bottom Line

The 20th century ran a massive experiment in political and economic systems. Over 100 million people died in communist countries—not from war with external enemies, from their own governments' policies.

The evidence is overwhelming. Communism produces poverty, oppression, and mass death. Every time similar countries with different systems are compared, the pattern holds.

This isn't just theory—it's written in the lives and deaths of hundreds of millions of people.

The proper response isn't to romanticize communism as a beautiful idea that was never truly tried. It's to learn from history's bloodiest lessons. Over the coming weeks, we'll explore what alternatives exist—socialism, democracy, and the capitalist republic—to understand which systems actually protect human dignity and create prosperity.

The alternative has been tried. It failed. Let's not repeat the experiment.

Everything = Everything

g